ETH Daily
Menu

Vitalik argues ETH’s value should not depend on fee burns

Historical report: Odaily published this account on November 9, 2026, based on a post by Vitalik Buterin on X that it described as appearing the previous evening. The figures and arguments below reflect that reporting, not a current market update.

Vitalik Buterin argued that Ethereum should place more emphasis on ETH as a store of value than on fee burns as the basis for its valuation. In the post reported and translated by Odaily, he said EIP-1559 and its burn mechanism should remain. But he argued that even if burns stayed below 10% of new ETH issuance over the long term, that would not mean ETH lacked other sources of value.

Why burns may not provide a valuation floor

Buterin described a simplified valuation model: divide the annual value of burned fees by a discount rate. Burning $1 billion a year indefinitely at a 4% discount rate would imply a valuation of about $25 billion. The difficulty, he argued, is that the fee revenue itself may fall when the crypto market weakens.

Ethereum burned substantial amounts of ETH from 2021 to 2023, but much of that activity came from within crypto. Buterin cited an NFT buying rush that burned roughly $180 million in fees in one day, alongside more routine lending activity. In his view, demand from outside crypto would make a fee-based valuation floor more credible. Growing real-world asset activity could help provide that demand, though he did not expect mature businesses to reproduce the fee spikes of speculative periods.

The trade-off in maximizing fees

Buterin argued that supporting ETH’s then roughly $270 billion market value primarily through burns could push Ethereum toward the spending and active governance of a major corporation. As an illustration—not a funding proposal or an adopted protocol change—he used an AI-generated estimate that L’Oréal’s annual research-and-development spending equaled about 0.58% of its market value. Applying a comparable approach to Ethereum, he estimated, could require around 700,000 ETH a year in protocol funding and reduce validator income by about two-thirds. He cautioned that these were estimates under a hypothetical scenario.

He also argued that pursuing higher fee burns can mean pursuing higher gas prices, potentially excluding users who most need privacy and security. Maximizing price × usage is not the same goal as serving as many people as possible within safe network resource limits.

What a store-of-value focus would prioritize

For Buterin, the central test of a store-of-value network is whether it can endure. He pointed to decentralization and what he called CROPS—censorship and capture resistance, open source, privacy and security—as qualities valued by individuals and institutions. His preferred direction includes cautious responses to quantum computing and AI, a more stable core protocol over time, and a high bar for features that add complexity or create rewards vulnerable to capture.

He cited multisignature wallets, privacy tools, privacy-focused account abstraction and FOCIL as work serving those goals; the report did not present them as a single activated upgrade. He also emphasized reducing dependence on infrastructure providers, saying he could run a node on a laptop that synchronized in under six hours while using about one-eighth of its disk space—a better result than in 2019.

Buterin saw room for application growth alongside this approach. More real-world and decentralized assets issued natively on Ethereum L1 could make ETH more useful for trustless exchange and as collateral, he argued. Such uses still involve trade-offs: shortening block intervals, for example, could increase centralization pressure. His distinction was between growth that preserves Ethereum’s security properties and making fee revenue the network’s overriding objective.

Source: odaily.news (originally published 2026-11-09 09:54 UTC+8)